Set 2025 Net Change Limit of 300M ADA, 2026 Net Change Limit of 250M ADA

System1y ago1 post
52 SPOs voted on this action, see how

On-chain changes

Informational action. No on-chain effect, the vote signals opinion only.

Abstract

As part of the budget approval process, it is necessary to establish a Net Change Limit. This serves as an opportunity for all governance stakeholders to formally express their positions regarding the proposed Net Change Limit, ensuring transparency, accountability, and alignment with organizational objectives.

2025 Net Change Limit of 300,000,000,000,000 lovelace (300M ada) 2026 Net Change Limit of 250,000,000,000,000 lovelace (250M ada) The Net Change Limit beyond 2027 is not defined in this governance action.

The Net Change Limit will be used when reviewing both budget actions and treasury withdrawal actions to ensure constitutionality as required by Article IV of the Constitution and the Treasury Withdrawal Guardrails outlined in Appendix I.

Motivation & rationale

Prior to the submission of any budget request, a Net Change Limit must be formally agreed upon. Failure to establish a Net Change Limit shall render any such budget request unconstitutional and, therefore, inapplicable.

The Net Change Limit shall be effective for the period specified in this action. In the event that a mutually agreed Net Change Limit is not established for subsequent periods, the most recently approved Net Change Limit shall remain in force by default.

The Net Change Limit shall remain in effect until such time as a new Net Change Limit is formally approved in accordance with the applicable governance procedures.

Just to clarify, we are not IOG, CF, EMURGO, PRAGMA, INTERSECT or their staff, we are just community members. We won't give names right now because we don't want to get caught up in any drama.

We submitted this proposal because we believe that any further delay in deciding on the Net Change Limit could result in significant opportunity losses for the Cardano ecosystem.

To maintain the sustainability and stability of Cardano's treasury, a Net-Change-Limit has been suggested, which would, if approved, set the constitutional and democratic mandate for the amount of ada that can be withdrawn from the Treasury over the 2025 period. The intent is to ensure that expenditures remain sustainable while enabling strategic investment in ecosystem growth.

Inflows into the treasury are forecast to be 300M ADA in 2025 and 265M ADA in 2026.

Therefore, capping Treasury spending at that amount is a conservative approach. (For ease of remembering, we proposed 250M ADA for 2026.)

If you are a DRep or ICC member who believes that the amount should be higher than this, we encourage you to vote for this Net Change Limit and then vote for a higher Net Change Limit if one is proposed. It is entirely possible to approve and set a higher Net Change Limit later.

This approach aims to:

  • Balance ecosystem growth with responsible treasury management,
  • Ensure funds remain available for ongoing and future initiatives
  • Provide clarity and predictability for all stakeholders

This limit shall be applied in assessing both budget actions and treasury withdrawal actions to ensure compliance with Article IV of the Constitution and the Treasury Withdrawal Guardrails specified in Appendix I of the Constitution.

In accordance with the Constitution, this action shall be considered ratified with a threshold of greater than 67% of the delegated ada to DReps voting in favor.

Note that the guardrail section of the Constitution states: TREASURY-01a (x) A net change limit for the Cardano treasury's balance per period of time must be agreed by the DReps via an on-chain governance action with a threshold of greater than 50% of the active voting stake.

However, the current DRep voting threshold for treasury withdrawals is set to 67%, so we align our proposed ratification threshold with this.

There is an opinion that the Net Change Limit should be treated as a percentage because the amount of inflow into the treasury changes every year. We think this is a great opinion in theory, but the downside of this opinion is the complexity of defining and agreeing on these. This governance action defines the Net Change Limit for 2025 and 2026 in accordance with the amount of inflow, addressing the concerns of those who say it should be defined as a percentage. Even if you are of the opinion that it should be defined as a percentage, we recommend that you carefully discuss and define an appropriate percentage and change the method after approving this governance action.

Rationale highlights

Why some of the largest DReps voted for and against, in their own words. About vote rationales

  • Yes482.8M ₳

    I am thinking of voting Yes for both Intersect-led NCL(350M-2025) and Community-led NCL(300M-2025,250M-2026). There are two reasons for this. Regarding the amount of NCL, I believe that Community-led NCL is better. Therefore, I will vote Yes for this. I...

    I am thinking of voting Yes for both Intersect-led NCL(350M-2025) and Community-led NCL(300M-2025,250M-2026).

    There are two reasons for this.

    1. Regarding the amount of NCL, I believe that Community-led NCL is better. Therefore, I will vote Yes for this. I will provide more details later.
    2. On the other hand, the worst-case scenario is that NCL is not agreed upon and set. To avoid this, I will also vote Yes for Intersect-led NCL. Although I believe that Community-led NCL is better, Intersect-led NCL is also acceptable in my opinion. I will provide more details later.

    Details of reasons and concerns

    1. Why I think Community-led NCL is better

    I will consider the pros and cons of Intersect-led NCL and Community-led NCL. I believe that Community-led NCL proposes a substantially better figure, so I will support it.

    1-a) Points where I think Community-led NCL is better than Intersect-led NCL.
    ・The inflow to the treasury in 2025 is clearly less than the inflow in 2024, so I think it would have been better to use the projected inflow for 2025. The logic behind using the actual results for 2024 did not seem very clear to me from the rationale in this governance action.
    ・It would have been better to set the NCL for 2026 at the same time. The current Intersect block budget appears to be scheduled so that all expenditures are made from the treasury in 2025, including items that may be fine to spend in 2026. Not defining the NCL for 2026 could be an incentive to unnecessarily bring forward spending plans in 2025.

    1-b) Points where I think the Intersect-led NCL is better than the Community-led NCL.
    ・The Intersect-led NCL is better organized in terms of format. This includes the definition of the NCL and its period.

    1. Reasons for voting Yes on the Intersect-led NCL at the same time

    In my opinion, the worst outcome is that the NCL is not agreed upon after all. With the trend of global deregulation of blockchain, if the NCL is not agreed upon, the creativity of the community is limited, and Cardano's progress slows down, it will be a big loss in terms of Cardano's vision and roadmap.

    One concern about voting Yes to both is the troubling question of what will happen if both NCLs are approved.

    2-a) If we consider that the 2025 NCL will be overwritten, we may end up with an NCL of 350M ADA applied in 2025 and an NCL of 250M ADA applied in 2026.

    2-b) The 2025 Net Change Limit does not contain any wording to the effect that "if this is adopted after the adoption of 'Set 2025 Net Change Limit of 300M ADA, 2026 Net Change Limit of 250M ADA,' the NCLs equivalent to 2025 in 'Set 2025 Net Change Limit of 300M ADA, 2026 Net Change Limit of 250M ADA' will be revoked." Therefore, if we consider that the 2025 NCL will not be automatically overwritten and that both NCLs will coexist and the stricter NCL will be applied, the 300M ADA NCL may be applied in 2025 and the 250M ADA NCL may be applied in 2026.

    This interpretation will likely be determined by the Constitutional Committee, but I believe that either interpretation is better than having no NCLs at all.

    *I have no particular conflict of interest related to this governance action.

    私は、Intersect主導NCLとコミュニティ主導NCLの両方にYes投票をしようと考えています。

    理由は2つです。

    1. NCLの金額については、私は、コミュニティ主導NCLの方がより良いと考えています。よってこれにYesを投票します。後ほど詳細を記載します。

    2. 一方で、NCLが合意されず設定されないというシナリオは最悪のシナリオです。これを回避するために、Intersect主導NCLにもYesを投票します。コミュニティ主導NCLの方がより良いと考えていますが、Intersect主導NCLも私の考えでは許容可能です。後ほど詳細を記載します。

    理由の詳細と懸念事項

    1. コミュニティ主導NCLの方がより良いと考える理由

    Intersect主導NCLとコミュニティ主導NCLのメリットデメリットを考えます。コミュニティ主導NCLの方が実質的に良い数値を提案していると考えているため、これに賛成します。

    Intersect主導NCLよりコミュニティ主導NCLの方が優れていると思う点。
    ・2025年の流入額は明らかに2024年の流入額より少ないため、2025年の流入額見込みを使用する方が良かったと考えています。2024年の実績を使った方が良いロジックはあまり私にとってこのガバナンスアクションに記載されるRationaleからは明確ではないように思えました。
    ・2026年のNCLも同時に設定した方が良かったように思えます。現在のIntersectのブロックBudgetは、おそらく2026年に支出しても問題ない可能性がある項目も含めて、2025年に全てトレジャリーから支出されるように支出スケジュールが組まれているように見えます。2026年のNCLが定義されないことで2025年に不必要に支出計画を前倒しするインセンティブになると可能性があります。

    コミュニティ主導NCLよりIntersect主導NCLの方が優れていると思う点。
    ・形式面はよりIntersect主導NCLの方がより良く整理されています。NCLやその期間の定義などです。

    1. 同時にIntersect主導NCLにもYesを投票する理由

    私が思うに、最悪の結末はNCLが結局合意されないことです。ブロックチェーンの世界的な規制緩和の潮流が巻き起こる中で、NCLが合意されず、コミュニティの創造性が制限され、Cardanoの歩みが遅くなることはCardanoのビジョンやロードマップから見て大きな損失です。

    両方にYesをする点の1つの懸念として、この2つのNCLが2つともに承認された場合に何が起こるのかは悩ましい問いです。
    2025年のNCLが上書きされると考える場合、2025年に350M ADAのNCLが適用され、2026年に250M ADAのNCLが適用される状態になるかもしれません。
    ・2025 Net Change Limitにおいて、「「Set 2025 Net Change Limit of 300M ADA, 2026 Net Change Limit of 250M ADA」が採択されたのちにこれが採択されたら、「Set 2025 Net Change Limit of 300M ADA, 2026 Net Change Limit of 250M ADA」の2025年に相当するNCLを取り消す」という旨の文言がないため、2025年のNCLが自動的に上書きはされず、両方のNCLが併存し、より厳しい方のNCLが適用されると考える場合、・2025年に300M ADAのNCLが適用され、2026年に250M ADAのNCLが適用される状態になるかもしれません。
    この解釈は、憲法委員会が判断を下すと考えられますが、いずれの解釈を取ったとしても、NCLが全く設定されない状態と比べるとより良いと私は考えています。

    *このガバナンスアクションに関連する利益相反は私には特にありません。

  • TL;DR: EDC voted NO. Setting the NCL for two years at once—even if we agree more with the 300M ADA limit—is not the right approach. As a community, we will refine the process in the coming months. There's no need to rush to set an NCL for 2026.

  • トレジャリーへの年間流入額が約300M ADAという実績に基づいて、その範囲内での運用を目指しているのは理解できますし、数字の根拠も明確です。ただし、この提案では2026年の上限まであらかじめ決めてしまうため、将来の予期せぬ状況変化に柔軟に対応しづらくなるというリスクがあると感じています。 Based on the actual annual inflow to the Treasury of approximately 300M ADA, it is understandable that you are...

    トレジャリーへの年間流入額が約300M ADAという実績に基づいて、その範囲内での運用を目指しているのは理解できますし、数字の根拠も明確です。ただし、この提案では2026年の上限まであらかじめ決めてしまうため、将来の予期せぬ状況変化に柔軟に対応しづらくなるというリスクがあると感じています。

    Based on the actual annual inflow to the Treasury of approximately 300M ADA, it is understandable that you are aiming to operate within that range, and the basis for the numbers is clear. However, we feel that there is a risk that this proposal will make it difficult to respond flexibly to unexpected future changes in circumstances, since it is predetermined up to the 2026 ceiling.

  • Yes120.1M ₳

    Why I Support the Community Proposal (300M ADA in 2025 / 250M ADA in 2026) Among the Net Change Limit (NCL) proposals currently under review in Cardano’s on-chain governance, I hereby clearly express my intention to vote Yes on the community-submitted...

    Why I Support the Community Proposal (300M ADA in 2025 / 250M ADA in 2026)

    Among the Net Change Limit (NCL) proposals currently under review in Cardano’s on-chain governance, I hereby clearly express my intention to vote Yes on the community-submitted proposal (gov_action10ue...yljxu5).

    This proposal sets the NCL for 2025 at 300 million ADA, and for 2026 at 250 million ADA. I believe this proposal is worthy of strong support not only because the numbers are reasonable, but because of its thoughtful structure, its emphasis on long-term sustainability, and its democratic, community-driven origins. It embodies the kind of governance culture we hope to foster in Cardano.

    ⸻

    1. A Responsible Limit Aligned with Treasury Realities

    The defining feature of this proposal is that the proposed NCLs closely match or modestly fall below the anticipated annual inflows to the treasury:
    • Estimated inflow for 2025: ~300M ADA → NCL: 300M ADA
    • Estimated inflow for 2026: ~265M ADA → NCL: 250M ADA

    This demonstrates a prudent approach, one that prioritizes optimal use of available resources rather than maximizing the spending ceiling. By aiming to operate within known income levels—possibly with some margin for reserve—this proposal upholds a core tenet of sustainable treasury governance: spend only what you can responsibly afford.

    In this regard, the proposal reflects a deep understanding of the NCL’s role as a constitutional safeguard—not a target, but a ceiling. The intent is not to spend to the limit, but to ensure spending does not exceed what the ecosystem can sustainably support.

    ⸻

    1. Multi-Year Design That Enables Predictability and Strategic Planning

    Another strength of this proposal is that it simultaneously defines NCLs for two consecutive years: 2025 and 2026. This multi-year scope enhances predictability for all stakeholders—DReps, vendors, community project teams—and enables strategic, forward-looking budgeting and development planning.

    In a global, decentralized ecosystem like Cardano, which aspires to long-term viability, year-by-year uncertainty in budgetary policy can inhibit both innovation and execution. By establishing NCLs for multiple years at once, this proposal sets a precedent for better foresight and strategic alignment, potentially serving as a model for other blockchain ecosystems to follow.

    ⸻

    1. A Flexible, Stepwise Governance Approach

    At first glance, the community proposal might appear conservative. However, it is crucial to recognize the explicit flexibility built into the proposal. The authors state clearly that, should the need arise, a higher NCL can be proposed and approved through the appropriate governance process.

    This represents an excellent example of adaptive governance—setting a safe starting point, with the openness to scale up when supported by evidence and community consensus. Rather than locking the network into a rigid or maximalist path, this proposal provides the flexibility needed to respond to emerging needs, while maintaining discipline and transparency.

    This approach aligns perfectly with the Cardano Constitution’s emphasis on sustainability, adaptability, and community-led governance.

    ⸻

    1. Grassroots Origins and Community-Centered Process

    One of the most compelling aspects of this proposal is its origin. It was submitted by anonymous members of the Cardano community, unaffiliated with IOG, CF, EMURGO, or Intersect. This independence reflects a grassroots commitment to decentralized governance.

    The proposers also explicitly ask the community to judge their proposal based on its merits and logic, not organizational affiliation. This demonstrates humility and a clear respect for the community’s intelligence and autonomy. In many ways, this proposal exemplifies Cardano’s ideals: decentralized, inclusive, evidence-based decision-making by and for the community.

    Trust in governance doesn’t come from institutional authority, but from clarity, transparency, and thoughtful participation—and this proposal checks all those boxes.

    ⸻

    1. A Realistic, Strategic Entry Point for Treasury Policy

    By setting the 2025 and 2026 NCLs at 300M and 250M ADA respectively, the proposal strikes a balance between enabling ecosystem funding and avoiding excessive market impact. These levels are unlikely to trigger large-scale inflationary pressure or significant ADA selloffs, which could depress market confidence and undermine treasury sustainability.

    In fact, this modest cap could foster greater trust in the treasury, by signaling that resources will be used with discipline and discretion. Moreover, starting with a conservative limit leaves room for further treasury innovation in the future, such as:
    • Guarded staking (self-staking treasury ADA to earn rewards)
    • Active reserve fund management
    • Diversification into stablecoins or native tokens (subject to governance)

    By leaving “headroom” for more advanced treasury strategies, this proposal lays the groundwork for the Cardano treasury to evolve from a passive store of funds into an active, resilient, and responsibly managed pool of shared resources.

    ⸻

    Conclusion: A Balanced NCL Proposal that Embodies Responsibility and Vision

    This community proposal presents a balanced, responsible approach to Cardano treasury governance. It is neither overly restrictive nor blindly optimistic. Rather, it reflects the maturity of a network that takes its public goods seriously, and is willing to tread carefully but confidently toward a sustainable financial future.

    As a DRep, I will vote Yes on this proposal not just because the numbers make sense, but because the spirit of the proposal—its prudence, its flexibility, its transparency, and its community-driven nature—aligns fully with my vision for Cardano.

    This is not simply about approving a budget cap. This is about affirming a governance culture: one that treats the treasury not as a spending account, but as a collective reserve for shared growth, responsibility, and legacy.

    As a member of this community, I’m proud to support such a thoughtful and principled proposal, and I will do everything in my power to ensure that its values are reflected and reinforced on-chain.

    Let’s build responsibly. Let’s build together. Let’s make the most of our shared future.

See all 68 rationales