Reimburse Ikigai Info Governance Action Deposit.
Discussed in the Governance Review for epochs 656 to 659.
143 DReps voted · 64 with a rationale · 3 changed their vote
Open a row to read the rationale.
Changed votes: 1 to yes, 2 to no, together voting with 95.8M ₳ of voting power.
Voting concentration
6 of 143 DReps cast half of the voted power.
Largest voter 12.0%, top 5 combined 45.5% of 3.7B ₳ voted.
The 19 largest voters together held as much voting power as the 67.0% threshold required in yes votes.
- YesRationale
Yes. Reimburse the Ikigai submitter 103,000 ADA for a deposit lost through a node bug plus fixed staking-reward compensation. The payment is bounded, directly traceable and consistent with my earlier support for correcting this loss.
A PDF version of this rationale is also made available.
Vote: Yes
I support the 103,000 ADA withdrawal to reimburse the Ikigai governance-action submitter: 100,000 ADA for the deposit lost after a node bug allowed an unregistered stake key, plus 3,000 ADA in staking-reward compensation. This is a specific, documented loss with a direct payment to the affected participant.
My position under the HOSKY Cardano First framework remains the same as my earlier support for this reimbursement. The previous treasury action expired without enactment. This resubmission asks governance to finish that correction.
Pillar analysis
Governance Transparency (lead pillar)
The proposal identifies the cause of the loss, separates the deposit from the additional compensation, and specifies the recipient. Payment occurs directly on enactment and can be checked on-chain. There is no delivery programme or intermediary spending process to supervise.
A governance system should have a clear way to correct losses caused by its own infrastructure. Leaving this unresolved places the cost of an early technical failure on the person who participated in good faith.
Economic Sustainability
The request is a one-time payment with a fixed amount. I accept the additional 3,000 ADA as the proposal's bounded allowance for lost staking rewards. It does not create an ongoing claim on future rewards or a recurring treasury commitment.
The justification is the documented deposit loss. Future reimbursement requests should be evaluated on their own evidence, including the technical cause, the amount and whether compensation has already been received.
Adoption
People need confidence that using Cardano governance will not leave them permanently carrying the cost of a system fault. Correcting this case supports that confidence. The benefit here is fair treatment of participants, rather than a measurable increase in transactions or commercial activity.
Risks I'm accepting with this Yes
1. A broader reimbursement expectation
Other participants may cite this payment in future claims. I accept that risk while keeping the principle narrow: documented infrastructure failure, an identifiable loss and a proportionate remedy. Approval does not establish a general refund policy for unsuccessful governance actions.
2. Compensation is an estimate
The additional 3,000 ADA is a fixed estimate of foregone staking rewards. I accept that approximation to resolve the matter without turning a limited reimbursement into an open-ended accounting exercise.
Decision
The amount is bounded, the payment is traceable, and the underlying reason for reimbursement remains sound. Yes.
- YesRationale
Looks to align with on-chain data and DRep sentiment to reimburse Ikigai due to an early governance bug.
DReps raise concern with the ask for additional ADA for staking rewards, although it's a nominal issue, and the proposer shouldn't be penalized for the rounding error.
Looks good to approve from a qualitative temp-check.
- YesChangedRationale
Reimburse Ikigai Info Governance Action Deposit. --> Yes
I am re-voting Yes for Ikigai reimburse deposit. I have confirmed the receiving address is valid. This was mistakenly deposited on Treasury especially in early times of on-chain governance. Deposit-risk should not be a barrier to the proposers. [Japanese version follows] ikigai アクションで誤って送金されたデポジットを返金する提案に対し、改めて賛成票を投じます。受領アドレスについて不明な点がありましたが、確認が取れました。この事案はガバナンス開始時のミスであり、許容されるべきと考えます。このようなミスを恐れることで提案をためらうような仕組みにすべきではない、という意図も含めます。
Earlier votes
No2mo agoSuperseded
eimburse the lost deposit for the Ikigai -- > No
I am voting NO on this Treasury Withdrawal of 103,000 ADA to reimburse the lost deposit for the Ikigai Info governance action. The rationale does not provide a transaction hash or on-chain evidence linking the deposit loss to the receiving address. Without verifiable proof that the recipient is the original submitter of the Ikigai governance action and that the deposit was forfeited due to the documented node bug, I am unable to confirm this withdrawal is directed to the correct party. I vote NO pending such verification. [Japanese version follows] Ikigai Infoガバナンスアクションのデポジット弁済を目的とした103,000 ADAのTreasury Withdrawalに対し、反対票を投じます。本提案のRationaleには、デポジット喪失と受取アドレスを結びつけるトランザクションハッシュやオンチェーン上のエビデンスが示されていません。受取人がIkigai GAの実際の提出者であること、およびデポジットが記載のノードバグによって回収不能となったことを確認できる証跡がない以上、この引き出しが正しい相手に向けられているかを判断することができません。検証可能なエビデンスが提供されるまで、反対票を投じます。
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesRationale
I support this reimbursement because it addresses a unique and exceptional case caused by a Cardano node bug during the early Chang era. The loss of 100k ada was not due to user error, and compensating this deposit is important for maintaining fairness and trust in the governance system. The requested amount is small, fully compliant with the NCL, and poses no meaningful fiscal risk. Given the special circumstances and the need to uphold governance integrity, I vote Yes.
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesRationale
Governance Action Review
Vote: YES
This governance action is materially equivalent to the previous submission on the same issue, and the voting position remains consistent with the prior assessment of this scope.
The purpose is limited and specific: to reimburse the 100,000 ADA deposit lost by the submitter of the original Ikigai Info governance action, plus 3,000 ADA in estimated lost staking rewards. The case does not involve funding a new project, creating an operational budget, or approving discretionary ecosystem spending. It concerns a corrective treasury withdrawal for an objective loss connected to an early technical issue in Cardano’s on-chain governance process.
The main concern in the previous assessment was whether the recipient of the reimbursement could be sufficiently linked to the original submitter affected by the lost deposit. That concern has already been addressed through the available on-chain verification showing continuity between the stake address associated with the original Ikigai action and the current reimbursement request.
Given that the new governance action maintains the same substantive scope, rationale, amount, and purpose, there is no reason to change the previous position. Approving this action is a matter of procedural fairness and institutional consistency. Refusing reimbursement in this specific context would create an unfair precedent for early governance participants who acted in good faith and were affected by a technical failure outside their control.
For these reasons, the vote remains YES.
Revisão da Ação de Governança
Voto: SIM
Esta ação de governança é materialmente equivalente à submissão anterior sobre o mesmo tema, e a posição de voto permanece coerente com a avaliação anterior deste mesmo escopo.
A finalidade é limitada e específica: reembolsar o depósito de 100.000 ADA perdido pelo submitter da ação de governança informativa original Ikigai, acrescido de 3.000 ADA em recompensas de staking estimadas que deixaram de ser recebidas. O caso não envolve financiar um novo projeto, criar um orçamento operacional ou aprovar gasto discricionário para o ecossistema. Trata-se de uma retirada corretiva do tesouro para reparar uma perda objetiva ligada a um problema técnico ocorrido no início do processo de governança on-chain da Cardano.
A principal preocupação na avaliação anterior era se o destinatário do reembolso poderia ser suficientemente vinculado ao submitter original afetado pela perda do depósito. Essa preocupação já foi endereçada pela verificação on-chain disponível, que demonstra continuidade entre a stake address associada à ação Ikigai original e a solicitação atual de reembolso.
Como a nova ação de governança mantém o mesmo escopo substantivo, a mesma justificativa, o mesmo valor e a mesma finalidade, não há razão para alterar a posição anterior. Aprovar esta ação é uma questão de justiça procedimental e consistência institucional. Recusar o reembolso neste contexto específico criaria um precedente injusto para participantes iniciais da governança que agiram de boa-fé e foram afetados por uma falha técnica fora de seu controle.
Por essas razões, o voto permanece SIM.
- YesRationale unavailable
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesRationale
With all concerns addressed, we are happy to proceed with a yes vote on this governance action. We consider the overall request to be reasonable and proportionate. Supporting this action reflects the principle that participants should not bear a significant financial loss resulting directly from a failure in the governance infrastructure. At the same time, our support should not be interpreted as establishing an open-ended Treasury compensation policy for indirect or opportunity losses.
- YesNo rationale
- YesRationale
Yes Remimburse Ikigai info governance Action Deposit
- YesRationale
Yes, refund the glitch!
- YesRationale
Vote: YES
This is a Treasury Withdrawal (gov_action105m...l5raht), proposed in epoch 649 and expiring epoch 656, requesting 103,000 ADA to reimburse the governance-action deposit lost by the submitter of the September 2024 Info action "Cardanoの生きがい - Ikigai." The 100,000 ADA deposit was trapped by a Cardano node defect that permitted an unregistered stake key to be used in a governance action, defeating the standard refund path. The remaining 3,000 ADA compensates approximately two years of foregone staking rewards on the stranded principal at roughly 2% annually.
Dracula DAO has already supported this remedy once, on the 100,000 ADA action that closed in July 2026, and the reasoning has not changed. This is not discretionary spending; it is remediation of a protocol failure. Cardano's governance deposit is designed to be fully refundable, and that guarantee is what makes it a legitimate anti-spam bond rather than a fee. The submitter posted the required bond in good faith within weeks of the Chang hard fork and lost access to it solely through a node-level defect. When the protocol breaks a refund guarantee it made, making the affected party whole preserves the integrity of the deposit mechanism and the credibility of participating in governance at all. The amount is fixed and small, the cause and recipient are clearly identified, there is no ADA burning, and there is no open-ended commitment.
The one new element is the 3,000 ADA rewards component, and Dracula DAO judges it reasonable rather than opportunistic. Delegated ADA earns staking rewards; ADA frozen in a broken deposit does not. Two years at roughly 2% on 100,000 ADA would be closer to 4,000 ADA, so the request is conservatively stated rather than padded. That said, Dracula DAO treats opportunity-cost compensation as acceptable here only because the delay is attributable to the protocol and to the community's own failure to resolve the matter promptly across multiple attempts, including the Cardano in Oceania budget action that was not approved. This is not a precedent for interest accruing on ordinary treasury claims.
Precedent and scope remain the real concern. A treasury reimbursement of a governance deposit must be understood as bounded strictly to funds stranded by a documented protocol bug, not as a general policy of socializing normally-refundable deposits, which would gut the deposit's anti-spam function by removing the submitter's skin in the game. The cleaner long-term fix is at the ledger level, so that stranded deposits are recoverable directly rather than requiring a treasury draw; a treasury withdrawal is the practical remedy available today, not the ideal one. Dracula DAO will oppose any future attempt to generalise this into routine deposit reimbursement absent a genuine protocol failure.
Dracula DAO's treasury philosophy centres on funding delivered work rather than operating budgets, and this action sits outside that frame entirely: it is neither a grant nor a budget, but the correction of a bond wrongly withheld by the system. Judged on fairness, low risk, and the health of the governance process, it clears the bar. Dracula DAO votes YES.
- YesRationale
It is unfortunate that it has taken this long, but I think this is only fair to reimburse Ikigai for being one of the first to submit a governance action on-chain and encountering this issue. Easy YES for me.
- NoRationale
前回と同じ判断です。こちらをご覧ください。\n\nMy decision remains the same as before. Please see here. (https://most-brass-sun.quicknode-ipfs.com/ipfs/Qmaq2pdB1uCoaii4tdyR6ccP1JqAJaEn6Fhpn39EDgn12g)
- YesRationale
Just to stay consistent with my previous votes on related matter
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesRationale
We have the ability to refund this early governance action, to support someone who was in the trenches in the early days.
- NoChangedHistory
Earlier votes
Yes2mo agoSuperseded
- AbstainNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesRationale
The "Reimburse Ikigai Info Governance Action Deposit" proposal requires withdrawing 103,000 ADA from the Treasury to refund the deposit to one user. This incident of losing 100,000 ADA occurred in September 2024 (right after the Chang hard fork) entirely due to a technical error of the Cardano node when allowing the use of unregistered stake keys, not due to the user's ignorance or mistakes. The additional 3,000 ADA is a completely reasonable compensation for the staking rewards they lost.
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- AbstainNo rationale
- YesRationale
This proposal reimburses the 100,000 ADA deposit lost by the submitter of the early Ikigai Info governance action because an early Cardano-node defect permitted an unregistered stake credential to be used as the deposit-return address, preventing normal recovery of the refundable deposit. The 103,000 ADA request consists of the lost principal plus a modest stated allowance for foregone staking rewards. The payment is immediate, direct, and publicly auditable on chain, with no continuing operational obligation or administrative custody. This is a proportionate resolution of a discrete loss caused by early governance-system behavior rather than proposer misconduct, and I therefore vote Yes.
- YesRationale
We should have done this a long time ago. I'm ashamed we have not resolved this situation.
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- YesNo rationale
- NoChangedHistory
Earlier votes
Abstain2mo agoSuperseded
- YesRationale
Maintaining my stance from my previous vote on this, I vote YES on the Treasury Withdrawal action "Reimburse Ikigai Info Governance Action Deposit." (7d37220b718064...78d9#0).
The stake address of "stake1uys93fhep4lc2u6lu0q09kcxayxzthasded35c0x0w60ugc9s0cm5" provided in the treasury withdrawal action matches that of the original Ikigai Info Action proposer, as verified on-chain using CardanoScan.
It is time to finally put this piece of Cardano governance history to rest once and for all.