Bifrost: Unlocking Bitcoin DeFi on Cardano — Road to Mainnet (Phase 1 of 2)

System4mo ago1 post

158 DReps voted · 57 with a rationale · 2 changed their vote · 2 re-voted unchanged

Open a row to read the rationale.

Changed votes: 2 to yes, together voting with 5.5M ₳ of voting power.

Voting concentration

7 of 158 DReps cast half of the voted power.

Largest voter 13.5%, top 5 combined 43.2% of 4.3B ₳ voted.

The 7 largest voters together held as much voting power as the 67.0% threshold required in yes votes.

  • Yes3.9M ₳Rationale

    [Portuguese]
    Optamos por votar "SIM" nesta ação de governança "Bifrost: Unlocking Bitcoin DeFi on Cardano — Road to Mainnet (Phase 1 of 2)" (gov_action1mlv...ms7jwt), pois entendemos que a proposta busca desenvolver uma infraestrutura estratégica para conectar a liquidez do Bitcoin ao ecossistema DeFi da Cardano, criando condições para ampliar o valor total bloqueado (TVL), atrair novos usuários, aumentar a atividade on-chain e expandir as oportunidades para aplicações descentralizadas e operadores de stake pools (SPOs). Embora o valor solicitado, de ₳12.332.031, incluindo uma contingência reembolsável de 10%, seja significativo, avaliamos que o orçamento está detalhado e concentrado em atividades essenciais, como desenvolvimento, auditorias, verificação formal e preparação para a implantação em mainnet. Consideramos que a relação entre custo e benefício é justificável diante da complexidade técnica e do potencial impacto da iniciativa para o ecossistema. Também avaliamos positivamente os mecanismos de governança, controle e transparência previstos na proposta, incluindo liberação de recursos condicionada ao cumprimento de marcos, utilização de contratos de escrow, supervisão por um conselho independente, auditorias técnicas e financeiras, relatórios públicos periódicos e registro transparente das movimentações. Esses mecanismos reforçam a responsabilidade na utilização dos recursos da Tesouraria e permitem o acompanhamento contínuo da execução do projeto pela comunidade.
    [English]
    We chose to vote "YES" on this governance action "Bifrost: Unlocking Bitcoin DeFi on Cardano — Road to Mainnet (Phase 1 of 2)" (gov_action1mlv...ms7jwt), because we believe the proposal aims to build strategic infrastructure that connects Bitcoin liquidity to Cardano’s DeFi ecosystem, creating opportunities to increase total value locked (TVL), attract new users, expand on-chain activity, and strengthen the ecosystem for decentralized applications and stake pool operators (SPOs). Although the requested ₳12,332,031, including a 10% refundable contingency, is substantial, we believe the budget is well structured and focused on essential activities such as software development, security audits, formal verification, and preparation for mainnet deployment. In our view, the proposal presents a reasonable cost-benefit balance given its technical complexity and potential long-term impact on the Cardano ecosystem. We also view the proposal’s governance, oversight, and transparency mechanisms positively. These include milestone-based fund releases, escrow-based Treasury management, oversight by an independent council, technical and financial audits, regular public reporting, and transparent disclosure of financial transactions. Together, these measures strengthen accountability and enable the community to effectively monitor project execution and the responsible use of Treasury resources.

  • Yes78.9M ₳Rationale

    I am voting YES to fund Phase 1 of the Bifrost Bitcoin-Cardano Bridge. Capturing Bitcoin's liquidity is the ultimate strategic prize for our DeFi ecosystem, and it is crucial to recognize that Bitcoin DeFi on Cardano originated with this exact team—it was their idea.

    A PDF version of this rationale is also made available.

    I am voting YES to fund Phase 1 of the Bifrost Bitcoin-Cardano Bridge. Capturing Bitcoin's liquidity is the ultimate strategic prize for our DeFi ecosystem, and it is crucial to recognize that Bitcoin DeFi on Cardano originated with this exact team—it was their idea, and they absolutely deserve this chance. I think a lot of the team; they are incredibly well-respected in our ecosystem for their technical execution. I am happy to put my voting power behind trusted teams that push Cardano forwards and build the high-impact infrastructure we need to stay competitive.

  • No215.3M ₳No rationale
  • Abstain55.4K ₳Rationale

    I vote ABSTAIN for this proposal

  • Abstain10.2M ₳Rationale

    The proposal needs improvement but if any team succeeds at this, it is Fluid

  • Yes3.4M ₳Rationale

    This actually seems to be a very useful and valuable solution for bringing Bitcoin to Cardano. For this proposal specifically, I'm willing to go a bit past my goal NCL of 100 Million ADA to hopefully get it passed.

    The key points that sell me - FluidTokens is working on this as a team member, and I know they can pull this off successfully. Also, there is no intermediary token, this will be community bridge architecture with no middle man, and it will be open sourced.

    This is 1000X better than the POGUN proposal, let's get it done!

  • Yes35.1M ₳Rationale

    Vote: Yes. This action requests 12,332,031 ADA for a nine-month Phase 1 that moves Bifrost from a working testnet to an audited bridge operating on Cardano mainnet under controlled access.

    A PDF version of this rationale is also made available.

    Cardano needs access to outside liquidity, and Bitcoin is the largest available source of crypto capital. A secure Bitcoin-to-Cardano bridge would allow BTC-backed assets to be used in trading, lending, collateral, and other Cardano applications. The Cardano First framework supports this proposal under Adoption.
    Bifrost is not starting from a concept. The bridge is operating on testnet and has completed approved Catalyst milestones. This request funds the next stage: protocol hardening, external audits, formal verification, penetration testing, SPO onboarding, partner preparation, and controlled mainnet deployment.
    The phased structure is important. This vote does not fund unrestricted public operation. Phase 1 must produce an audited bridge and on-chain evidence before the team returns with a separate Phase 2 request for public launch and ongoing operations.
    Bridges carry serious smart-contract, cryptographic, operational, and custody risks. I accept those risks because funding is milestone-gated, independently overseen, held under restricted administration, and subject to return mechanisms for unused funds. Security work takes place before public exposure.
    Cardano cannot grow as an isolated economy. Bifrost is existing technology with a controlled route toward one of the largest liquidity opportunities available to the network.
    I vote Yes.

  • Abstain73.3M ₳Rationale

    I am voting Abstain on the Bifrost: Unlocking Bitcoin DeFi on Cardano Road to Mainnet (Phase 1 of 2) proposal.

    I rate the direction and design highly. SPO threshold custody is the right approach built on Cardano's structural strengths, and with no bridge token, no founder allocation, open-source release, and fee surplus returning to the Treasury, this is close to public infrastructure worth Treasury support.

    Still, approval is difficult at this point.

    First, cost. Phase 1 alone is about 1.97 million dollars (12,332,031 ADA), with Phase 2 for launch and operations planned separately at about 1.3 million, putting the full commitment near 3.3 million dollars. The proposal should be judged against that total, and at the Treasury's current capacity that is not a scale to approve lightly.

    Second, sequencing. Bifrost's Catalyst Fund 14 milestones are not yet complete. The verifiable order is to finish and evaluate the prior work first, then request funding for the next stage.

    I recognize the public-good design, but given the total cost and the incomplete prior work, I am withholding support for now. If resubmitted after Catalyst completion, I would actively reconsider.

  • Yes993.4K ₳No rationale
  • Abstain228.7M ₳Rationale

    A well thought out system. We would love to see it succeed. But please consider the feedback of NO votes from various DReps.

  • Abstain213K ₳Rationale

    Abstain due to personal involvement

  • No474.2K ₳Rationale

    A PDF version of this rationale is also made available.

  • Yes115.6K ₳No rationale
  • Yes13K ₳No rationale
  • Yes0 ₳No rationale
  • No29M ₳Rationale

    I am a big fan of FluidTokens and Lantr, but this proposal is a bit too expensive for my liking. There are also a handful of other BTC liquidity solutions competing in this space and I am not convinced that the ROI for public funds is quite worth it considering the many alternatives.

  • Yes10.7M ₳Rationale

    RCADA votes YES on Bifrost: Unlocking Bitcoin DeFi on Cardano — Road to Mainnet (Phase 1 of 2).

    This is a cautious YES for high-potential strategic infrastructure.

    RCADA supports this proposal because a credible Bitcoin-to-Cardano bridge could be strategically important for Cardano. Bitcoin remains the largest pool of capital in the digital asset ecosystem, but most BTC is not actively used in DeFi because holders remain cautious about custody, bridge security, signer sets, and cross-chain risk. If Cardano can provide a more security-oriented route for BTC liquidity to enter its DeFi ecosystem, that could strengthen Cardano’s TVL, transaction activity, user base, and broader financial relevance.

    Bifrost’s design is ambitious but aligned with Cardano’s strengths. The proposal aims to create a permissionless Bitcoin-Cardano bridge where locked BTC is secured through Cardano’s SPO ecosystem using threshold signing, and where bridged BTC appears on Cardano as a native Cardano asset, fBTC. This could allow wallets, DEXs, lending markets, and other applications to integrate BTC liquidity through Cardano’s existing native asset model.

    RCADA recognises that Bifrost is not simply another DeFi product. If successful, it could become shared ecosystem infrastructure. The proposal includes no separate bridge token, no founder allocation, open-source Apache 2.0 licensing, public reporting, and a planned independent stewardship structure. These features strengthen the public-good case and reduce the concern that the Treasury is funding a private protocol or speculative token model.

    RCADA also notes that Bifrost is not starting from zero. The bridge is already funded through Catalyst Fund 14, with testnet work underway and several milestones reported as completed or on track. The proposal states that the bridge is live on testnet, with working peg-in flows, participating SPOs, and interest from Cardano applications that may integrate Bifrost or fBTC.

    The request is significant at 12,332,031 ADA for Phase 1. RCADA does not treat that lightly. However, cross-chain bridges are among the most security-sensitive infrastructure in DeFi, and underfunding security would be irresponsible. This proposal allocates substantial resources to hardening, external audits, cryptographic review, formal verification, penetration testing, bug bounty work, and controlled mainnet deployment. For infrastructure that may eventually secure real BTC, these are core requirements.

    RCADA is reassured by the phased structure. This proposal does not fund a full public launch or two years of operations. It funds the road to audited mainnet readiness under controlled private access. Public rollout and operations would require a separate Phase 2 proposal. RCADA’s YES vote is therefore support for proving Bifrost safely before public launch, not automatic support for future funding.

    RCADA has carefully considered the risks. Bitcoin bridges carry serious smart-contract, cryptographic, custody, operational, liquidity, regulatory, and reputational risks. The SPO-threshold custody model is promising but complex. The federated fallback must be clearly governed and tightly constrained. The independent stewardship structure is also not yet established and remains a Phase 1 deliverable.

    However, RCADA does not believe these risks are too high for the specific scope of Phase 1. This phase is mainly about reducing and validating risk before public launch through audits, formal verification, threat modelling, controlled mainnet testing, transparency tooling, stewardship setup, and economic-model validation.

    RCADA expects the team to publish audit reports, formal verification outputs, mainnet contract addresses, custody-mode evidence, successful peg-in and peg-out transaction proofs, transparency portal data, SPO participation metrics, and stewardship documentation. Critical findings should be remediated before any public launch, and any accepted residual risks should be clearly disclosed.

    On balance, RCADA believes Bifrost is a high-potential infrastructure proposal with serious but appropriately addressed Phase 1 risks. RCADA votes YES because this proposal funds a security-first road to mainnet readiness, not a rushed public launch. This support is conditional in spirit on rigorous security delivery, transparent reporting, independent stewardship, controlled risk exposure, and no assumption of automatic Phase 2 approval.

    RCADA's full vote assessment can be found here:
    https://brolloks.github.io/rcada-drep-votes/

  • No12.5M ₳Rationale

    We vote no on this governance action because the proposal does not sufficiently address several critical questions that are necessary to justify a treasury allocation of ₳12.33 million. Given the scale of the request and the systemic importance of cross-chain infrastructure, we believe that greater clarity, stronger accountability mechanisms, and more concrete evidence are required before community funds can be responsibly committed.

    First, the proposal does not clearly define the objective criteria that would constitute the successful completion of Phase 1 and unlock Phase 2 funding. What specific technical, security, and operational milestones must be achieved before additional treasury resources are requested? More importantly, how will these milestones be independently verified by the community, and what mechanisms will exist to ensure accountability if the deliverables fall short of expectations?

    Second, the security assumptions underlying the Bitcoin–Cardano interoperability model remain insufficiently explained. What trust assumptions are embedded within the bridge architecture, who controls the critical infrastructure, and what safeguards exist against validator compromise, economic attacks, or catastrophic failures? Given the history of exploits affecting cross-chain protocols across the industry, the proposal should explicitly outline its threat model, contingency plans, and the precise scope of independent security audits.

    Third, the economic justification for allocating ₳12.33 million from the treasury is not adequately demonstrated. What measurable outcomes, such as total value locked, transaction volume, user adoption, or developer activity, does the team expect to generate, and over what timeframe? Without clear performance indicators and evidence that Bitcoin users will meaningfully migrate to Cardano-based DeFi, it is difficult to assess whether the anticipated ecosystem benefits justify the magnitude of the investment.

    Fourth, the proposal does not provide a sufficiently detailed sustainability strategy beyond the requested funding period. How will the protocol's infrastructure, maintenance, and operational costs be financed once treasury support ends? If future treasury requests are anticipated, what is the long-term roadmap toward financial self-sufficiency, and how will the community avoid creating a permanent dependency on treasury funding?

    Finally, the proposal lacks transparency regarding prior funding history and the current state of development. What funding has Bifrost previously received through Catalyst, private investment, grants, or other treasury allocations, and which milestones have already been delivered with those resources? A complete accounting of past investments and outcomes is essential for DReps to evaluate whether this proposal represents an efficient and responsible use of community funds.

  • Abstain817.5K ₳No rationale
  • Yes16.4M ₳Rationale

    Vote: YES

    This is a Treasury Withdrawal, "Bifrost: Unlocking Bitcoin DeFi on Cardano — Road to Mainnet (Phase 1 of 2)" (gov_action1mlv...ms7jwt), submitted July 3, 2026 with voting closing August 2, 2026. FluidTokens and Lantr Engineering request ₳12,332,031 (approximately $1.97M at the $0.16/ADA reference rate) over nine months, July 2026 through March 2027, to harden Bifrost — a permissionless Bitcoin-Cardano bridge that brings BTC onto Cardano as a native asset (fBTC) with custody distributed across 400+ SPOs using FROST threshold signatures — through external audits, formal verification, penetration testing, and private mainnet deployment. Public launch and operations are deferred to a separate Phase 2 proposal. No ADA burning is involved.

    The accountability structure is the strongest Dracula DAO has seen in the 2026 cycle. Funds are held in a SundaeSwap treasury-contracts escrow previously audited by TxPipe and MLabs; every disbursement requires co-signature from a three-person independent oversight board drawn from Blink Labs, the Cardano Foundation, and IOG; No.Witness Labs provides quarterly technical review and an independent financial auditor reviews fund use post-delivery; unused funds return automatically to the treasury on contract expiration, and the 10% contingency (₳1.12M) is explicitly refundable. The three milestones are concrete and verifiable — M1 an audit-ready hardened release candidate, M2 completed external audits and formal verification with both custody modes tested, M3 private mainnet with real BTC. The project is not vapor: the bridge is live on Bitcoin Testnet4 and Cardano Preprod with peg-ins occurring, five SPOs participating, and seven dApps expressing integration interest. There is no bridge token, no founder allocation, and no extractive tokenomics; the code is Apache 2.0. Lantr has disclosed prior treasury funding of ₳657,692 fully received and delivered on the Scalus platform. Distributing bridge custody across the SPO set rather than a small signer committee is the right architectural instinct, and it creates a revenue stream for stake pool operators beyond block production.

    The concerns are real. ₳12.33M is priced as a team operating budget — $210K per FTE-year across 52.5 FTE-months — rather than as a grant against completed features, and there was no competitive bidding for the work. Phase 1 produces no public deliverable: at its end there is a privately deployed, audited bridge and a further Phase 2 request for public launch and 24 months of operations, so a YES here is the first half of a commitment whose full cost is not yet on the table. Cross-chain bridges are the single most exploited category of infrastructure in this industry, and stake-weighted SPO threshold custody is unproven at scale — the residual risk is bounded by the private-mainnet rollout and an early TVL cap, but it is not eliminated. The withdrawal also lands with ADA near multi-year lows, so the treasury pays in its weakest currency. DRep support is currently narrow, at approximately ₳939M yes against ₳909M no.

    Dracula DAO votes YES. Treasury funds should be awarded as grants paid on completion of well-defined features, and this proposal does not fully meet that standard — it is a budget, and Dracula DAO names that gap plainly. But the gap is narrower here than in anything else this cycle: money moves only when an independent board with no financial stake in the outcome signs off against a defined milestone, undelivered funds go back to the treasury automatically, and what is being bought in Phase 1 is precisely the thing Dracula DAO has demanded of every bridge proposal — audits, formal verification, and adversarial testing completed before a single retail user is exposed. Paying for security before launch rather than after an exploit is the ultra long-term posture this DREP exists to defend. Dracula DAO's NO on Pogun in May 2026 was structural, not technical: Bitcoin DeFi infrastructure on Cardano is worth building, and the objection was to pre-funding a team roadmap with no delivery gating. Bifrost answers that objection directly.

    Dracula DAO will judge Phase 2 entirely on delivery. If M1 through M3 are not completed and independently verified on the stated schedule, or if the audits surface material findings in the custody model, the Phase 2 request for public launch and operations will be opposed. This vote funds proof, not permission.

  • Yes9.2K ₳Rationale unavailable
  • Abstain31.9K ₳No rationale
  • No150.5M ₳Rationale

    The Cardano Foundation votes NO. We recognize the team's delivery to date, however this proposal raised concerns about subsequent phase dependency, no vendor detail and concurrent Treasury requests from this team in the same window.

    A PDF version of this rationale is also made available.

    The Cardano Foundation recognizes FluidTokens and Lantr Engineering as capable teams. The bridge is live on testnet, Catalyst milestones have been delivered and approved, and the combined engineering bench covers Bitcoin scripting, Cardano contracts, and threshold cryptography. We also agree with the premise that Cardano would benefit from a secure route to Bitcoin liquidity. Our NO vote is not a rejection of that objective, nor of this team, but of this proposal on the information provided.

    Our decision is driven by the following factors:

    1. Phase 1 does not stand on its own. 12.33 million ada funds an audited bridge on mainnet under controlled, private access. No public peg-ins, no fBTC in circulation, no TVL, no SPO revenue. Every ecosystem benefit set out here activates in Phase 2, a separate request of approximately $1.3 million in Q1 2027, with no commitment on either side that it will be made or approved. The Treasury would underwrite the larger and harder half of a two-part programme while holding no claim on the second. We would expect either a Phase 1 scope that delivers standalone value or a single request covering both phases in detail.
    2. Concurrent delivery load is not addressed. Lantr Engineering is carrying a separate Treasury request of 8,503,000 ada for the Scalus platform over July 2026 to June 2027, the same window as Phase 1.
    3. The largest budget lines are unspecified and internally inconsistent. Approximately $875,000 of fixed costs sits across three workstreams without vendor-level detail, including the $550,000 for audits and formal verification that this proposal exists to fund, with no audit or verification firm identified and no split given between the two vendors who must co-sign every disbursement. Annex 1 states six FTE-months each for ecosystem readiness and for legal and stewardship; the budget table funds three of each, and the 52.5 subtotal only reconciles at three. The blended rate of $210,000 per FTE-year at $100 per hour implies 2,100 billable hours, above ordinary senior-engineer capacity. Milestone gating and the oversight board are genuine controls, but they govern release, not the basis of the estimate.
    4. The custody design is described but not committed. The proposal states that custody is distributed across 400+ SPOs weighted by delegation, requiring a threshold representing a majority of delegated stake. Operator eligibility, the reward formula, key re-sharing as stake moves, and the smallest coalition capable of reaching the threshold are not specified. We accept that final parameters are M1–M3 work. We would still expect the bounds within which they will be set to be published before Cardano's operators are asked to secure Bitcoin.
    5. Currency exposure runs one way. Funding is requested at a $0.16/ADA reference rate, with a portion hedged into stable assets after disbursement. Only unspent contingency returns. If ada appreciates over the term, the surplus stays with the vendors and the hedge fixes it there. A symmetric true-up would leave both sides where the proposal says it intends them to be.

    We have not rested this vote on the market sizing or on Annex 2. The $1.6 trillion figure is used loosely across the ecosystem, and the share of BTC deployed in DeFi is close to the proposal's estimate when measured on a like-for-like cross-chain basis. While the basis of the estimate is vague, it is not grounds to decline overall.

    The Cardano Foundation votes NO on this governance action. We would review a revised submission on its merits, and we encourage the proposers to scope Phase 1 so that it delivers standalone value or to combine both phases into a detailed single ask, disclose and resource the concurrent delivery commitment, break out the fixed budget at vendor level and reconcile Annex 1 with the budget table, publish the bounds of the custody design including the minimum signing coalition, and make the currency true-up symmetric. Cardano should fund a Bitcoin rail, and we look forward to a proposal we can support.

    ---

    > **_NOTE on 'Internal Voting':_**

    > The fields _constitutional_ and _unconstitutional_ below reflect the CF governance teams' individual opinions whether they are _for_ or _against_ the proposal. Reason for this inconsistency is, that CIP-136 is at the moment only applicable to CC rationales, but we want to record the internal opinions of our DRep assessment transparently as well.

  • Yes109.5K ₳No rationale
  • Abstain0 ₳Rationale

    本提案が目指すBitcoin DeFiの実現やCardanoへの流動性導入という方向性には価値があると考えます。また、チームのこれまでの実績や技術的な取り組みも評価しています。一方で、約₳12.3MというTreasury支出については、現時点では期待される成果と投資規模のバランスについて十分な確信を持つには至りませんでした。そのため、本提案には賛成・反対のいずれともせず、棄権します。\n\nI recognize the value of this proposal's goal of bringing Bitcoin DeFi and liquidity to Cardano, and I appreciate the team's track record and technical work. However, I have not yet reached a sufficient level of confidence regarding the balance between the expected outcomes and the scale of the approximately ₳12.3M Treasury withdrawal. Therefore, I abstain on this proposal.

  • Yes1.1M ₳No rationale
  • Abstain614.1K ₳Rationale

    I abstain with strong support for Bifrost. Current NCL has only twelve point six million ADA remaining and Bifrost at twelve point three million would exhaust it. I encourage the team to resubmit after the NCL increase passes when I will support enthusiastically.

    A PDF version of this rationale is also made available.

    I am voting Abstain on this proposal. While I strongly support the Bifrost vision and believe the team has delivered excellent accountability and technical rigor, the current Net Change Limit leaves only approximately twelve point six million ADA in remaining headroom after the recently enacted Daedalus proposal. Bifrost requests twelve point three million ADA which would consume virtually all remaining fiscal capacity under the current three hundred fifty million ADA limit. This would leave no room for the DeFi Kernel proposal and other pending Treasury requests that I also support. I do not oppose Bifrost on its merits. The public value is clear, the SPO secured custody model is innovative, and the accountability framework is best in class. However fiscal stewardship requires me to prioritize proposals that fit within the available budget while preserving headroom for other ecosystem needs. The DeFi Kernel proposal at three point three million ADA leaves substantially more room for additional proposals compared to Bifrost at twelve point three million. I strongly encourage the Bifrost team to resubmit this proposal once the Net Change Limit increase to five hundred million ADA is approved. At that point the fiscal constraint is resolved and I would enthusiastically support this proposal on its merits.

  • Yes32M ₳Rationale

    This proposal funds the hardening, audits, formal verification, and SPO‑threshold readiness required to bring the already‑working Bifrost testnet bridge to mainnet readiness. Secure BTC inflow is one of Cardano’s largest strategic opportunities, and fBTC as a native asset directly contributes to TVL, transaction volume, and user growth. Phase 1 is limited to public‑infrastructure preparation, with Phase 2 (public launch) separated appropriately. Given the strong Catalyst delivery record and the clear public‑good nature of this work, I vote Yes.

  • No83.3M ₳No rationale
  • Abstain102.1K ₳Rationale

    Governance Action Review Report [EN]

    1. Introduction

    Bifrost is a permissionless Bitcoin–Cardano bridge secured by Cardano’s existing Stake Pool Operator ecosystem. It is intended to bring BTC onto Cardano as a native asset that applications can integrate into trading, lending, collateral, and other financial use cases. The bridge is currently operating on testnet under a Catalyst Fund 14 grant.

    This Governance Action requests ₳12,332,031, approximately US$1,973,125 at a reference rate of US$0.16 per ADA, including a 10% refundable contingency. The nine-month delivery period runs from July 2026 to March 2027.

    The withdrawal funds Phase 1 of a two-phase program. It covers bridge hardening, external security audits, formal verification, ecosystem and partner readiness, and the institutional and economic foundations required for launch. By the end of Phase 1, Bifrost is expected to operate on Cardano mainnet under controlled access in both federated and SPO-threshold custody modes. Public rollout and 24 months of operations are excluded from this withdrawal and are intended to be funded through a separate Phase 2 proposal in Q1 2027.

    2. Governance Action Analysis

    Positive aspects

    The proposal presents a level of preparation and detail far above the average of the Treasury Withdrawals submitted during this cycle. The technical scope is extensively explained, milestones are provided, oversight mechanisms and audits are planned, and an architecture has already been developed on testnet. The teams demonstrate adequate technical capacity and have a positive history of delivering Catalyst-funded projects, with no significant known delays.

    This formal and technical merit prevents the proposal from being treated as poorly prepared or clearly unfeasible. There is a genuine attempt to structure objectives, indicators, and accountability mechanisms, something that many proposals apparently regard as an administrative extravagance.

    The number of participating SPOs is an exception among the adoption indicators. The target of 400 SPOs in the sixth month, growing to 500 in month 24, is ambitious and directly connected to the legitimacy of the architecture. The whitepaper acknowledges that security depends on the participation of a weighted majority of participating SPOs, making this indicator structurally more important than a common promotional KPI.

    The budget provides some granularity by workstream and presents FTE-months. The blended rate of US$100 per hour does not appear clearly inflated when compared with blockchain engineering, cryptography, or specialized security work in the North American market.

    Negative aspects

    The main limitation concerns the usage and adoption KPIs. Although targets are presented for TVL, wallets, transactions, integrations, and SPO participation, these indicators belong to the future Phase 2 launch and operations plan. The current action funds only Phase 1, which ends with an audited bridge on private mainnet under controlled access. Therefore, the principal economic outcomes used to justify the project are not binding success criteria for this withdrawal.

    The proponents classify the adoption targets as provisional, to be hardened during Phase 1 and finalized in the future Phase 2. This means they may be modified before the next funding request. Should the second phase not be submitted or approved, the targets would never become enforceable. The existence of these KPIs remains positive, but their value as a current accountability mechanism is limited.

    Even when the complete program is considered, the adoption targets appear weak to reasonable in relation to the problem the proposal intends to address. Cardano has experienced low TVL, low liquidity, and difficulty attracting external capital for years. Several DeFi initiatives have already received funding and completed technical deliverables without producing relevant economic adoption. In this context, the delivery of another functional infrastructure project does not provide sufficient confidence that the historical result will be different.

    The targets of 1,200 BTC in the Base scenario and 3,000 BTC in the Bull scenario after 24 months represent material capital for Cardano’s current ecosystem, but would not necessarily place Cardano anywhere near a leading position among the principal DeFi blockchains. For infrastructure whose central justification is connecting Cardano to the largest pool of capital in crypto, the targets do not appear sufficiently strong to compensate for the ecosystem’s negative adoption history.

    The budget still operates essentially through a blended rate of US$100 per hour applied to different functions. This rate is also applied to product, partnerships, administration, economic work, and other activities with different salary references.

    Thus, the most precise conclusion is that the rate is not evidently outside the market; it does not represent a bargain for the Treasury; the generic calculation reduces the ability to verify the real cost of each function; positions, seniority, committed individuals, and the distribution of hours are absent; relevant fixed costs remain insufficiently detailed; and cost-effectiveness depends on adoption that is not contracted during this phase.

    Risks and concerns

    The primary uncertainty concerns the ability to transform technical delivery into actual usage. Cardano’s DeFi ecosystem has already funded multiple initiatives that delivered technical products without generating proportional liquidity, volume, or external capital inflows.

    The cost-effectiveness of Phase 1 depends on future adoption outcomes that are not binding under the current withdrawal. The main economic indicators may be revised, and they become enforceable only through a future proposal that may not be submitted or approved.

    Given the Treasury’s financial situation and the elevated compensation standards accepted across several proposals in this cycle, a rate that is merely defensible under the international market is insufficient to establish strong economic efficiency. The Treasury should require more competitive conditions when it assumes almost all the risk of infrastructure whose demand has not yet been demonstrated.

    3. Vote and Rationale

    Vote: ABSTAIN

    The vote is not YES because Phase 1 is not linked to the main adoption KPIs; those KPIs are provisional and may be revised; the economic targets appear modest in relation to the project’s ambition and the sector’s history; the budget is reasonable, but not economical; and substantial uncertainty remains regarding the ability to transform technical delivery into actual usage.

    The vote is also not NO because the proposal is exceptionally well detailed; the team demonstrates technical capacity and a history of execution; milestones, audits, and control mechanisms are provided; the costs do not appear clearly inflated; and there is an above-average attempt to define KPIs and sustainability.

    Abstention therefore represents recognition of the technical merit without endorsement of the economic thesis. There is insufficient evidence to affirm that the investment will produce adoption proportional to its cost, but the quality of the proposal and the planned execution also do not justify categorical rejection.

    4. Conclusion

    The technical quality, execution history, milestones, audits, and control mechanisms prevent categorical rejection. However, Phase 1 does not bind the project to its principal adoption outcomes, the economic targets remain provisional and modest, and the budget does not provide sufficiently strong economic efficiency. The resulting vote is ABSTAIN.


    Relatório de Revisão de Ação de Governança [PT]

    1. Introdução

    Bifrost é uma ponte permissionless entre Bitcoin e Cardano, protegida pelo ecossistema existente de Stake Pool Operators da Cardano. Seu objetivo é trazer BTC para a Cardano como um ativo nativo que possa ser integrado por aplicações em negociações, empréstimos, garantias e outros casos de uso financeiro. A ponte está atualmente operando em testnet por meio de um financiamento do Catalyst Fund 14.

    Esta Ação de Governança solicita ₳12.332.031, aproximadamente US$1.973.125 a uma taxa de referência de US$0,16 por ADA, incluindo uma contingência reembolsável de 10%. O período de execução é de nove meses, entre julho de 2026 e março de 2027.

    A retirada financia a Phase 1 de um programa dividido em duas fases. Estão incluídos o hardening da ponte, auditorias externas de segurança, verificação formal, preparação do ecossistema e de parceiros, além das bases institucionais e econômicas necessárias para o lançamento. Ao final da Phase 1, espera-se que Bifrost opere na mainnet da Cardano, sob acesso controlado, nos modos de custódia federado e por threshold de SPOs. O lançamento público e 24 meses de operações não fazem parte desta retirada e deverão ser financiados por uma proposta separada de Phase 2 no primeiro trimestre de 2027.

    2. Análise da Ação de Governança

    Aspectos positivos

    A proposta apresenta nível de elaboração e detalhamento muito superior à média das Treasury Withdrawals submetidas neste ciclo. O escopo técnico é amplamente explicado, há milestones, mecanismos de supervisão, auditorias previstas e uma arquitetura já desenvolvida em testnet. As equipes demonstram capacidade técnica adequada e possuem histórico positivo de entregas financiadas pelo Catalyst, sem atrasos significativos conhecidos.

    Esse mérito formal e técnico impede que a proposta seja tratada como mal elaborada ou claramente inviável. Há uma tentativa genuína de estruturar objetivos, indicadores e mecanismos de accountability, coisa que muitas propostas aparentemente consideram uma extravagância administrativa.

    O número de SPOs participantes é uma exceção entre os indicadores de adoção. O alvo de 400 SPOs no sexto mês, crescendo para 500 no mês 24, é ambicioso e está diretamente ligado à legitimidade da arquitetura. O whitepaper reconhece que a segurança depende da participação de uma maioria ponderada dos SPOs participantes, tornando esse indicador estruturalmente mais importante do que um KPI promocional comum.

    O orçamento possui alguma granularidade por workstream e apresenta FTE-months. O rate blended de US$100/h não parece claramente inflado quando comparado a engenharia blockchain, criptografia ou segurança especializada no mercado norte-americano.

    Aspectos negativos

    A principal limitação está nos KPIs de uso e adoção. Embora sejam apresentados alvos de TVL, wallets, transações, integrações e participação de SPOs, esses indicadores pertencem ao futuro plano de lançamento e operações da Phase 2. A ação atual financia apenas a Phase 1, que termina com uma ponte auditada em private mainnet e acesso controlado. Portanto, os principais resultados econômicos que justificam o projeto não são critérios de sucesso vinculantes desta retirada.

    Os próprios proponentes classificam os alvos de adoção como provisórios, a serem endurecidos na Phase 1 e finalizados na futura Phase 2. Isso significa que poderão ser modificados antes da próxima solicitação. Caso a segunda fase não seja submetida ou aprovada, os alvos nunca se tornam exigíveis. A existência dos KPIs continua sendo positiva, mas seu valor como mecanismo atual de accountability é limitado.

    Mesmo considerando o programa completo, os alvos de adoção parecem fracos a razoáveis diante do problema que a proposta pretende enfrentar. Cardano convive há anos com baixo TVL, baixa liquidez e dificuldade para atrair capital externo. Diversas iniciativas DeFi já receberam financiamento e concluíram entregas técnicas, mas não produziram adoção econômica relevante. Nesse contexto, a simples entrega de outra infraestrutura funcional não oferece confiança suficiente de que o resultado histórico será diferente.

    As metas de 1.200 BTC no cenário-base e 3.000 BTC no cenário Bull após 24 meses representam capital material para o atual ecossistema Cardano, mas não colocariam necessariamente Cardano em posição de destaque entre as principais blockchains DeFi. Para uma infraestrutura cuja justificativa central é conectar Cardano ao maior pool de capital cripto, os alvos não parecem suficientemente fortes para compensar o histórico negativo de adoção do ecossistema.

    O orçamento ainda funciona essencialmente com um rate blended de US$100/h aplicado a funções diferentes. Esse rate também é aplicado a produto, partnerships, administração, trabalho econômico e outras atividades com referências salariais distintas.

    Assim, a conclusão mais precisa é que o rate não está evidentemente fora do mercado; não representa uma barganha para o Tesouro; o cálculo genérico reduz a capacidade de verificar o custo real de cada função; faltam cargos, senioridade, pessoas comprometidas e distribuição de horas; custos fixos relevantes continuam pouco detalhados; e o custo-benefício depende de uma adoção que não é contratada nesta fase.

    Riscos e preocupações

    Permanece elevada incerteza sobre a capacidade de transformar entrega técnica em uso real. O ecossistema DeFi da Cardano já financiou diversas iniciativas que entregaram produtos técnicos sem gerar liquidez, volume ou entrada de capital externo em proporção equivalente.

    O custo-benefício da Phase 1 depende de resultados futuros de adoção que não são vinculantes na retirada atual. Os principais indicadores econômicos poderão ser revisados e somente se tornarão exigíveis por meio de uma futura proposta que poderá não ser submetida ou aprovada.

    Diante da situação financeira do Tesouro e do padrão de remuneração elevado aceito em várias propostas do ciclo, um rate simplesmente defensável pelo mercado internacional não é suficiente para caracterizar boa eficiência econômica. O Tesouro deveria exigir condições mais competitivas quando assume quase integralmente o risco de uma infraestrutura cuja demanda ainda não está demonstrada.

    3. Voto e Justificativa

    Voto: ABSTAIN

    O voto não é YES porque a Phase 1 não está vinculada aos principais KPIs de adoção; esses KPIs são provisórios e podem ser revistos; os alvos econômicos parecem modestos diante da ambição e do histórico do setor; o orçamento é razoável, mas não econômico; e permanece elevada incerteza sobre a capacidade de transformar entrega técnica em uso real.

    O voto também não é NO porque a proposta é excepcionalmente bem detalhada; o time demonstra capacidade técnica e histórico de execução; existem milestones, auditorias e mecanismos de controle; os custos não parecem claramente inflados; e há uma tentativa superior à média de definir KPIs e sustentabilidade.

    A abstenção representa, portanto, reconhecimento do mérito técnico sem endosso da tese econômica. Não há evidência suficiente para afirmar que o investimento produzirá adoção proporcional ao custo, mas a qualidade da proposta e da execução planejada também não justifica uma rejeição categórica.

    4. Conclusão

    A qualidade técnica, o histórico de execução, os milestones, as auditorias e os mecanismos de controle impedem uma rejeição categórica. Entretanto, a Phase 1 não vincula o projeto aos principais resultados de adoção, os alvos econômicos permanecem provisórios e modestos, e o orçamento não apresenta eficiência econômica suficientemente forte. O voto resultante é ABSTAIN.

  • Yes529.5K ₳No rationale
  • Yes3.1M ₳No rationale
  • Yes1.3M ₳No rationale
  • Abstain29.1M ₳Rationale

    I understand the arguments from both sides. On one hand, Bitcoin DeFi is an important opportunity for Cardano, and I believe this type of infrastructure could provide meaningful long-term value. On the other hand, given the current Treasury constraints and the current value of ADA, I am hesitant to support additional spending of this size at this time. If ADA were in a stronger position, I would likely be inclined to vote in favour. For now, I believe abstaining is the most appropriate decision.

  • Yes960.2K ₳No rationale
  • Yes202.9K ₳No rationale
  • Abstain170.3M ₳No rationale
  • No1.2M ₳Rationale

    I vote NO on "Bifrost: Unlocking Bitcoin DeFi on Cardano - Road to Mainnet (Phase 1 of 2)". It is a promising open-source approach to bringing Bitcoin liquidity to Cardano, and its escrow, independent oversight, security work, and potential future Treasury return are meaningful strengths. However, I do not think 12,332,031 ADA should be committed before the Catalyst-funded testnet project is fully delivered, independently assessed, and clearly reconciled with this next scope. Phase 1 ends with a private deployment while public launch, operations, and a further funding request remain ahead, creating too much budget and delivery uncertainty under current Treasury pressure. I would prefer a dedicated Catalyst-style programme for high-risk strategic infrastructure and would reconsider Bifrost after final Catalyst evidence and a clearer full path to public operation.

  • No1M ₳No rationale
  • Abstain110.7M ₳No rationale
  • No57.9K ₳No rationale
  • Yes490.7K ₳No rationale
  • Yes146.3K ₳No rationale
  • Yes120.1M ₳Rationale

    SIPO DRep votes YES, with expectations, on the treasury withdrawal "Bifrost: Unlocking Bitcoin DeFi on Cardano - Road to Mainnet (Phase 1 of 2)" (12,332,031 ada).

    This action funds the work required to take Bifrost from a working testnet to launch readiness over nine months, from July 2026 to March 2027: hardening, security audits, formal verification, partner and ecosystem readiness, and the stewardship and economic foundations for launch. The request is 12,332,031 ada, modelled at approximately $1,973,125 at $0.16 per ada and including a 10% refundable contingency. Public rollout and 24 months of operations are deliberately separated into a Phase 2 proposal in Q1 2027. The proposers are FluidTokens and Lantr Engineering. The on-chain recipient is a script credential at stake179nmtusegux540zeqwpyapfjfvpxy75qxu4weq2emvcztqgtmwxw2, the stronger fund-control class.

    SIPO supports this. Bitcoin is the largest pool of capital in crypto and remains almost entirely outside DeFi, and the binding constraint is not demand but the security assumptions holders must accept in order to leave the Bitcoin base layer. What distinguishes Bifrost from existing routes is where custody sits: not with a company, a foundation, or a fixed signing committee, but distributed across Cardano's stake pool operator set, weighted by delegation. That is a materially different trust model from the wrapped-BTC designs that dominate today, and it is assembled from infrastructure Cardano already has rather than from a new trusted party. Bringing BTC onto Cardano as a native asset that lending, trading, and collateral applications can compose with is genuine ecosystem infrastructure, and it is the category the treasury exists to fund.

    SIPO notes plainly that it operates stake pools, and that a design giving stake pool operators a new economic role in securing BTC custody is one from which SIPO would stand to benefit. SIPO states this rather than leaving it implicit. It does not change the assessment, which rests on the custody model and the audit gating, but the reader is entitled to know it.

    SIPO attaches expectations. First, this is Phase 1 of 2, and a Yes here is not a commitment to Phase 2: SIPO will judge the 2027 operations request on delivery, not on continuity. Second, custody of real BTC should not go live before the audit and formal verification results are published and the identified issues resolved; the sequencing in this proposal is correct, and SIPO expects it to be honoured under schedule pressure rather than compressed. Third, the stake pool participation model - eligibility, economic terms, and what happens when a participating pool fails or misbehaves - should be published in enough detail that operators can evaluate the commitment before taking it on. Fourth, Lantr Engineering is also delivering the Scalus 2026 work that SIPO supports in this same batch; SIPO expects reporting to evidence that the two are separately staffed. None of these conditions the vote; they are the basis on which SIPO will judge delivery. This vote is SIPO DRep's recorded position.


    SIPO DRep は、トレジャリー引き出し提案「Bifrost: Unlocking Bitcoin DeFi on Cardano - Road to Mainnet (Phase 1 of 2)」(12,332,031 ADA)に、期待事項を付して賛成(YES)を投じます。

    本件は、Bifrost を稼働中のテストネットからローンチ可能な状態へ引き上げるために必要な作業を、2026 年 7 月から 2027 年 3 月までの 9 ヶ月間にわたり資金手当てするものです。堅牢化、セキュリティ監査、形式検証、パートナーおよびエコシステムの準備、そしてローンチに必要な運営体制と経済的基盤が対象です。要求額は 12,332,031 ADA($0.16/ADA でモデル上 約 $1,973,125)で、返還可能な 10% のコンティンジェンシーを含みます。一般公開と 24 ヶ月の運用は、2027 年 Q1 の Phase 2 提案として意図的に分離されています。提案者は FluidTokens と Lantr Engineering です。オンチェーン受領先は script credential(stake179nmtusegux540zeqwpyapfjfvpxy75qxu4weq2emvcztqgtmwxw2)で、資金統制としては強い類型です。

    SIPO はこれを支持します。ビットコインは暗号資産で最大の資本プールでありながら、その大半がいまだ DeFi の外側にあります。制約は需要の不足ではなく、保有者がビットコインのベースレイヤーを離れる際に受け入れざるを得ないセキュリティ上の前提にあります。Bifrost が既存の経路と異なるのは、カストディの所在です。企業でも財団でも固定署名委員会でもなく、委任量で加重された Cardano の SPO 群に分散されます。これは現在主流のラップド BTC 設計とは実質的に異なる信頼モデルであり、新たな信頼主体を持ち込むのではなく Cardano が既に有するインフラから組み上げられています。BTC を Cardano 上のネイティブ資産として持ち込み、レンディング・取引・担保の各アプリケーションが合成できる状態にすることは、本物のエコシステムインフラであり、国庫が担うべき類型です。

    SIPO は、自らがステークプールを運用していること、そして SPO に BTC カストディ保全という新たな経済的役割を与える設計から SIPO 自身が受益し得る立場にあることを、明示的に記します。SIPO はこれを暗黙にせず述べます。評価そのものはカストディモデルと監査ゲートに基づいており本点で変わりませんが、読み手はこれを知る資格があります。

    SIPO は期待事項を付します。第一に、本件は 2 段階のうち Phase 1 であり、ここでの賛成は Phase 2 への約束ではありません。2027 年の運用要求は継続性ではなく履行実績で判断します。第二に、実際の BTC のカストディは、監査および形式検証の結果が公開され、指摘事項が解消される前に本番稼働すべきではありません。本提案の順序設計は正しく、SIPO はそれがスケジュール圧力の下で短縮されず遵守されることを期待します。第三に、SPO の参加モデル(参加要件、経済条件、参加プールが障害を起こした場合や不正を行った場合の扱い)は、各オペレーターが引き受け前に評価できる程度に詳細を公開すべきです。第四に、Lantr Engineering は SIPO が同じ batch で支持する Scalus 2026 も担当しています。SIPO は、両者が別個の人員体制で遂行されていることが報告で示されることを期待します。これらはいずれも本投票の条件ではなく、SIPO が履行を判断する際の基礎です。本投票は SIPO DRep の記録上の立場表明です。

  • Abstain1.8M ₳Rationale

    Abstaining, as I would prefer to see the Bifrost Catalyst project completed first (or at least on the final milestone).

  • Abstain6.6M ₳No rationale
  • Abstain21.5M ₳No rationale
  • Yes394.8K ₳No rationale
  • No9.6M ₳Rationale

    dOSPO/OMF: Still abstain.

    ALPHAGROWTH: YES. I support this proposal because growing Cardano's DeFi ecosystem, liquidity, and competitiveness is a strategic priority. While I would have preferred stronger attribution and performance metrics upfront, I believe the proposal contains sufficient milestone-based funding, reporting, and governance oversight to justify support. On balance, the opportunity cost of delaying a coordinated growth initiative outweighs the remaining execution risk.

    Bifrost: NO. While I support Bitcoin interoperability as a concept, I am not convinced this proposal sufficiently demonstrates the value it will create for Cardano relative to its cost. This is the first phase of a multi-phase initiative that explicitly anticipates a future Treasury proposal for launch and operations, yet the proposal primarily relies on the expectation that Bitcoin liquidity and activity will naturally translate into meaningful value for Cardano. I would have preferred stronger evidence that this infrastructure is likely to drive measurable adoption, on-chain economic activity, and sustainable benefit to the ecosystem before committing Treasury funding to a longer-term roadmap.

    Version 12 von Bergen: ABSTAIN, however know that this is starting to get a bit morbid.

    Cardano Enterprise Ticketing: ABSTAIN. I support enterprise adoption as a strategic priority for Cardano, and I believe this proposal represents a legitimate opportunity. However, I remain divided on whether this is the right path for funding initiatives of this nature. I would have preferred to see enterprise opportunities evaluated through a dedicated catalyst or accelerator-style program rather than as standalone Treasury withdrawals. Given that uncertainty—and the broader community's differing views on the appropriate funding model—I am abstaining.

  • Yes980K ₳No rationale